A pros and cons list puts one choice at the top, the arguments for it in one column and the arguments against it in the other. You then weigh the items instead of counting them. The point is to see every reason at once, so you judge the whole decision rather than whichever worry is loudest.
That is exactly what helps when you have been turning a choice over for days, whether it is a job offer, a move to another team or which of two approaches to recommend at work. Done well, the list gets you unstuck. Done carelessly, it simply writes down the answer you were already leaning toward, and the difference comes down to a few choices about how you build it.
How a pros and cons list works
Start with one decision, framed as a single choice you can say yes or no to. “Should I accept the offer from the agency?” works far better than “What should I do about my career?” Write the pros on one side and the cons on the other. Then, before you read anything into the result, ask how much each item actually matters.
That last step is where most lists go wrong. The number of items in each column tells you very little. An option with five pros and three cons is not the right choice if one of those three cons is serious, because counting treats a minor convenience and a dealbreaker as if they were the same size. A shorter commute and a nicer office do not outweigh a role that teaches you nothing. Weigh the items, and the list becomes useful precisely when the stakes are highest.
The idea goes back at least to 1772, when Benjamin Franklin described it in a letter to his friend Joseph Priestley. Franklin was open about its limits. He said it was not precise arithmetic, but that with each reason considered separately and comparatively, and the whole laid out in front of you, you judge better and are less likely to take a rash step. That is the right expectation to bring. A pros and cons list does not decide for you. It slows the decision down enough for your judgment to do its job.
Five types of pros and cons list
Not every decision needs the same format. The basic two-column list is one version; the others each fix a specific weakness in it, whether that is equal weighting, missing information or too many options.
The simple two-column list
The classic T-chart: a line down the middle of the page, pros on the left, cons on the right, one choice at the top. It is the fastest format and the right one for everyday decisions, such as whether to volunteer for a project or ask to move a deadline. Its strength is that every reason sits in one view. Its weakness is that it treats every item as equal unless you deliberately weigh them, so use it together with the weighing step above, not instead of it.
Franklin’s prudential algebra
Franklin’s own method adds two things to the simple list: time and trade-offs. He kept the sheet open for three or four days and added short notes as reasons came to him, because some considerations only surface later or in a different mood. A list written in ten minutes while you are stressed tends to capture the immediate worries and miss the slower, longer-term effects.
Once the list was complete, he estimated the weight of each item and struck out items that balanced each other: a pro and a con of equal weight, or one pro against two cons that together equaled it. What survived the crossing out showed him where the balance lay. It remains the best version for a decision that can wait a few days, such as a job offer with a deadline next week.
The weighted pros and cons list
A weighted list gives each item a score for importance, say 1 to 5, and compares the column totals. This forces you to state how much each item matters instead of leaving it as a vague feeling. It helps most when the two columns are about the same length and the decision turns on which items matter most. Keep in mind that the scores are your own estimates. A total of 23 against 19 looks precise, but it is only as sound as the judgments behind each number.
PMI: plus, minus, interesting
PMI, a technique developed by Edward de Bono, adds a third column for points that are neither clearly good nor clearly bad. That is where uncertainties, implications and open questions go: the team is being reorganized next year, or you do not yet know how much travel the role involves. A strict two-column list either drops these points or forces them into the wrong column. In a PMI, the interesting column often turns out to be the most useful one, because it shows you what you still need to find out before you decide.
A comparison matrix for three or more options
A standard pros and cons list evaluates one choice, or at most two. With three or more options, such as three job offers or several ways to solve a problem at work, separate lists become hard to compare fairly, because each one ends up with different items. A comparison matrix fixes this. List the criteria that matter down the side and the options across the top, then score every option on the same criteria. The totals are comparable because each option answered the same questions.
Why the list can mislead you
Every version shares one weakness: it only contains what you think to write down. That makes it vulnerable to cognitive biases, and above all to confirmation bias. If you already lean toward accepting an offer, pros will come to you easily and cons slowly, and you will tend to score them in the same direction. The list then looks like analysis while it simply records a decision you have already made.
Two more traps are built into the method. First, Franklin’s approach does not separate how important an outcome is from how likely it is. A con that would be serious but is improbable can end up weighing as much as one that is almost certain, so ask of each item both “how much would this matter?” and “how likely is it?” Second, pros and cons do not automatically cancel each other out. A con only offsets a pro when the two are genuinely linked, such as good warranty cover offsetting a car’s tendency to break down. A higher salary and a longer commute are not linked. They are a trade-off you have to judge, not a sum you can subtract.
The fix for bias is outside input. Ask someone who sees the choice differently to add items to your list, or deliberately write the strongest case for the option you favor least. It also helps to know your own tendencies. Some people rush decisions, others overthink them, and most have a default they fall back on under pressure. Knowing how you decide makes it much easier to notice when a list is being stacked in your favor, and a default is a habit you can change, not a fixed part of who you are.
When the list gives you no clear winner
Sometimes you do everything right and the columns still come out close. That is information, not failure. A close result usually means both options are reasonable, and that you are looking for a certainty the decision cannot give you. In a real choice, no option comes with an empty cons column.
If you have been waiting for one, you are in good company. One of the people we interviewed about working life told us:
No job is ever going to give me everything. Whatever I choose, there will always be something another role could offer me that my current one cannot.
Strangely enough, that has given me a sense of calm. I can appreciate what I’m getting from the job I have now, rather than constantly wondering whether I should be somewhere else or looking forward to whatever comes next.
He did not find a perfect option; he stopped expecting one. That is a useful stance for any close call. Settle for a good-enough choice rather than holding out for a flawless one, and check three things before you commit. Is any con a dealbreaker, an item that rules an option out whatever the rest of the list says? Which open questions could you settle with one conversation or one email? And when you picture the list pointing one way, do you feel relief or disappointment? That reaction shows you what you really weighted, whatever the numbers say.
What makes your list worth trusting
Look at where a pros and cons list succeeds or fails, and the format is rarely the reason. What decides it is how honestly you weigh the items, what you count as mattering in the first place, and who sees the reasoning before you act.
Decision-Making. A list is only as good as the process around it, and this skill covers what the columns cannot. It means basing items on facts rather than impressions, getting another opinion before you trust the tally, slowing down when you are rushed or emotional, and accepting good enough when the result comes out close. It also means catching the traps that tilt what gets written down, such as confirmation bias or the sunk-cost trap, where the time already spent on one option makes it look better than it is.
Setting Goals. Many of the lists that matter most early in a career are about a job: whether to accept an offer, whether to leave a role that does not fit, which of two paths to take. The weighting in those lists has to come from your own work values and strengths. A salary pro counts differently for someone who values security than for someone driven by self-expression, and a con a parent or friend calls serious may matter little to you. This skill is how you learn which items deserve the heavy scores.
Working with Your Manager. At work, a pros and cons list is often something you bring to your manager rather than keep to yourself. Laying out two options with their trade-offs is the practical form of bringing solutions, not just problems: your manager can see your reasoning and agree, adjust or overrule it quickly. It also clarifies where your decision-making authority ends, so you know which calls are yours to make and which are yours to prepare.
Which of the three would help you most is hard to judge from the inside. The Job Skills Test measures all three, along with the rest of the twelve workplace skills it covers, and each of them improves with practice, so it is worth taking a few minutes to see which to build first before your next close call.
What you already bring to a hard choice
Some of this may already be part of how you work, even if you have never called it a method. If you have ever written a list, seen where it pointed and felt your stomach drop, you have already noticed the gap between what you wrote down and what you actually care about. Careful weighing is built to close exactly that gap. The rest can be learned: checking your own bias, weighting by your own values, showing your reasoning to the person who has to sign off. None of it asks you to become more cautious or more decisive than you are. It asks you to make your reasoning visible, to yourself and to others.
The choices ahead will get bigger, with more responsibility, more people affected and often less time to decide. Deciding well carries more weight as that happens, and it grows with every decision you make on purpose rather than by default. A sensible place to begin is knowing where you stand today.
See where you stand before your next decision
The only thing left is one practical step.
The Job Skills Test is a free self-assessment of your work skills. You answer questions about how you actually act at work, and in 7 minutes you see where you stand across all twelve skills, including Decision-Making, and which ones would make the biggest difference to the choices ahead of you.
Free, takes 7 minutes, and your results appear instantly.
Related skills
Related guides
10 Examples of Managing Up You Can Start This Week
Ten concrete examples of managing up, from status updates to timing your asks, with what each looks like in practice, when to use it, and what to avoid.
10 Signs of Micromanagement at Work (and What They Actually Mean)
The clearest signs of micromanagement at work, how to tell them apart from normal close supervision, and what actually helps you earn back some room.
3 Month Review: What Actually Happens, and How to Prepare
A 3 month review is a checkpoint, not automatically a verdict. What your manager will ask, how to prepare, and what to do with the feedback.
6 Decision-Making Models and When to Use Each
Six decision-making models — rational, satisficing, intuitive, recognition-primed, creative, and Vroom-Yetton — with a clear guide to when each one works best.
7 Performance Evaluation Examples, and Why Each One Works
Seven performance evaluation examples, from accomplishments to areas for improvement and goals, with weaker and stronger versions and why each one works.
8 Employee Goals Examples for Your Performance Review
Eight employee goals examples for a performance review - output, quality, development and behavioral - plus how to pick ones your manager will agree to.